The Catholic Fundraiser

6 Secrets to Rock Multi-Channel Integrated Nonprofit Fundraising Campaigns

Posted by Claire Axelrad on 9/8/16 11:56 AM


This article includes 6 expert tips and best practices for any business, including a non-profit, wanting to run an integrated marketing campaign that generates more potential donors and raises more dollars.

Wait! What is an integrated marketing campaign?

An integrated marketing campaign is a marketing effort that uses a consistent message across traditional and non-traditional marketing channels. Ultimately all the messages should reinforce each other. Integrated marketing campaigns enable brands (yes, your nonprofit is a brand) to reach new audiences and gain mass exposure for their marketing promotions. Plus, in the information overload world in which we live, folks need to see your message multiple times before their brain will process it (Did you know that, on average, only 16% of Facebook fans will see what you share)?

There used to be a marketing “Rule of 7” stating that a prospect needs to hear the advertiser’s message at least 7 times before they’ll take action to buy that product or service. Guess what? That rule was invented by the movie industry in the 1930’s! It takes a lot more impressions today (I’ve heard as many as 21).

So a multi-channel campaign is the way to go. Whether you reach folks 7 or 21 times, or somewhere in between, your messages should range over different sorts of media. Consider emails and newsletters, social media posts, website and blog, direct mail, advertising and even in-person presentations. But it can’t be a big mish-mash. You’ve got to integrate everything to ensure all your media channels are working together. That’s how you will ultimately get noticed.

To illustrate how this might work for you, here is an example of an integrated campaign that spanned seven geographically separated Rescue Missions. Together, they launched an integrated summer campaign challenge that was dubbed “Give the Gift of Hope.” It included custom branded Facebook posts, a custom targeted Facebook pay-per-click (PPC) campaign and newsletter/ email blasts.

1. Be consistent.

Did you know that custom-branded “donate” pages nested inside a nonprofit’s website will raise 6 times more money? This means creating a donate page that uses the same language, colors, fonts and images as your campaign, rather than simply sending folks to one generic page. Consistency also means every piece of creative you design for your campaign must be consistent across all channels, both online and offline. As mentioned, the Rescue Missions Summer Challenge included seven different local and regional nonprofits, each with their own logo, unique brand and preferred fonts. A challenge for sure, but not impossible if approached strategically! In this case, care was taken to both reinforce the campaign theme and fit each individual branch’s brand requirements. The Rescue Missions maintained the design colors and theme throughout their other marketing materials, like their ads and social media images.

2. Add a hashtag.

When you’re working with multiple campaigns, multiple platforms and multiple businesses, a hashtag can be the one thing that pulls it all together! Rescue Missions chose two hashtags to include with their Summer Challenge, #GiveHope and #SummerChallenge. This allowed them to track everyone who was talking about and sharing their campaign online.

3. Use the same form to collect entry information.

Even though each Rescue Mission had their own campaign published to a variety of Facebook pages and websites, they had one consistent goal: to raise $10,000 during the month of May. They hired outsourced online design experts to build a single form to collect entrants’ information across all of their channels. This kept their entries organized and made it easy for them to track participation across multiple channels and businesses. 

4. Have a strong call-to-action.

If you’re running an integrated marketing campaign, it’s important that your campaign design will emphasize the actions that will help you achieve your goals. In the Rescue Missions’ campaigns, the goal was to raise $10,000. Each campaign email and Facebook post included a large, red “Donate Now” button and a meter that let fans know details about their fundraising goals. For example, if your goal is to build your mailing list by getting people to enter your promotion, put the emphasis on your “Submit” button. If you’re offering a valuable download, put the emphasis on your “Download Here” button. 

4. Have an advertising plan.

Integrated marketing campaigns are meant to gain mass exposure and the way to help achieve this is to create an ad campaign that will run alongside your promotion. This will allow you to reach a larger audience and drive traffic back to the variety of places your campaign is published.

5. Add multiple promotion channels. 

The more places you can run your campaign, the better. If you know where your target markets hang out, prioritize those channels. The Rescue Missions favored Facebook, so their integrated marketing campaign could be found on all seven of the Rescue Missions’ Facebook Pages, all seven websites and as custom-branded landing pages. That’s 21 different places they were able to collect data and drive traffic from! On top of that they used Facebook posts, newsletter/ email blasts and a Facebook PPC campaign to promote their fundraiser.

Further Examples of an Integrated Marketing Campaign

Furthermore, the Rescue Missions’ key integrated campaign did several things very effectively. Here are some examples that you might find helpful for your integrated campaign:

  1. They incorporated imagery/ branding from each individual Rescue Mission at the top of their webpages.
  2. They included the “Give the Gift of Hope” campaign tagline at the top of their webpages.
  3. They used the “Join our Summer Challenge Today” campaign call to action consistently.
  4. They told compelling stories to capture folks' attention.
  5. They made it easy for folks to read the full story by including clickable links that took them back to the organization’s website.
  6. They made use of a specific challenge grant to create a strong impetus to leverage donor giving.
  7. They included a clear deadline to create urgency.
  8. They used a thermometer to create a sense of campaign momentum and emphasize how the donor’s gift would make an impact.
  9. They included a large, clickable “Donate” button in a bright contrasting color.
  10. They provided opportunities for additional engagement via “like our page” buttons and a fill-in form to join their email/newsletter list.
  11. They included basic contact information at the bottom, should folks want to be in personal contact with the organization.

Lastly, your key to success is simply this: (1) multiple channels; (2) consistent branding, and (3) simple, user-friendly content. Now go on and rock your multi-channel social media, and online/offline fundraising strategy!

Looking for more great content? Subscribe to Catholic Fundraising Weekly for a weekly digest of the latest news in fundraising!


Topics: Donor Development, Catholic Fundraising Resources, Multi-Channel Marketing

Written by Claire Axelrad

Claire Axelrad, J.D., CFRE was named Outstanding Fundraising Professional of the Year by the Association of Fundraising Professionals and brings 30 years frontline development experience to her work as principal of Clarification. A sought-after coach, Claire teaches the CFRE Fundraising Certification Course and frequently presents for The Foundation Center and 4GOOD. Claire writes regular columns for Nonprofit Pro, Guidestar and Maximize Social Business. Clarification was named “Best Fundraising Blog of 2013” by FundRaising Success Magazine.

About The Catholic Fundraiser

In this weekly blog we share tips, tactics and case studies for professionals in the Catholic fundraising community. Learn how to advance your mission with articles on technology, donor engagement, nonprofit leadership, social media, and emerging trends.

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts